Reviews for Stuart's Seafood Market Ltd in Amagansett, NY
It?s just not the same under new ownership. Three times we?ve bought whole fish, which has smelled absolutely rancid in under... 24 hours after squeezing lemon all over it and stuffing it with herbs to marinate. When you go in to the shop and even ifyou?re only looking for seafood, make a point to look at the produce?it?s on the cusp of being rotten. What a shame. Read more
As others have said, it?s not the same. Not even close. Every single order I call in is messed up and when I complain, they?re... mad at me like I did something wrong. There are too many seafood shops out here to deal with this nonsense any more. They?velost a very good (like, VERY good), very long-time customer. Do not order from there if your meal is dependent on it because Iguarantee it wont be what it should be. Read more
This is a sad review to leave since we?ve loved Stuart?s for years. The new owners have just raised prices to where it?s crazy,... steamers are $12 or more a pound? I can get two pounds of steamers in a restaurant for less than it would cost me to cook themmyself. We?ll have to start shopping somewhere else for seafood. Read more
If you're thinking anything seafood Stuarts is place . First and foremost they're good people. The seafood is always fresh,... local, and if you want lobsters cooked and cracked you will not find better. they are open year round which is also great. Ican with full confidence recommend Stuarts for all your seafood needs and their prepared foods are also great. soups, salads,etc. Read more
Always a great choice for seafood and other delectable items with a friendly and competent staff. The plank barbecued salmon is... a favorite! Read more
Stuart Seafood Market has all the fixin?s for any foodie. Make this place your next stop when preparing your lobster dinner..... Well worth the visit! #shoplocal Read more
Nice cute place. Doesn't have crabs, but has a weight-based variety of lobsters. Has more than just the ordinary fish, mussels,... and lobsters, like salads or steaks. Pricing is a bit expensive. Got a one and a half pound lobster and two pounds of musselsfor around 30$. Read more
Fantastic selection! Clam pies (a hyper-local). Possibly the best lobster bisque I've ever had!