Reviews for Shibley's at the Pier in Alton Bay, NH
One of Alton bay?s favorites. We?ve eaten here a few times and have always had a excellent dining experience. Friendly &... attentive staff, the food was great. The menu has selections for any taste from the appetizers, soups, salads, to the maindinner selections. The outdoor lakeside deck seating is very popular so you can expect a wait at lunch or dinner times duringpeak season. Read more
I have been going there for years always ALWAYS been satisfied but today was a terrible experience. My $24 cheese burger tasted... like old meat, the onions were definitely not sliced fresh as they had zero taste, the cheese on my burger was not melted, thepoppers were cold.. and ta boot we were there for an hour and a half for lunch part of that was a 20 minute wait for our check?I wonder if COVID has gutted their experienced staff? I spent over $100 for a lunch that wasn?t as good as the $13 square burger fast food joint I stopped at on the way home!! Read more
Lovely view and delicious food! I had the fried Haddock sandwich and the key lime pie and they were both delicious! Service was... friendly and efficient. Sit outside if you can because of the lake is gorgeous! Read more
Our first visit. We had a 5pm reservation for the deck and, even though we were 9 minutes early, we were seated almost... immediately. Our server, Nicki, came to get our drink order in mere minutes and was super attentive during our visit. Myfiancé had the warm spinach salad with roasted duck breast and I had the seafood risotto. Both were fantastic. Nicki wasgreat and i highly recommend a visit. 5 out of 5 stars. Read more
Awesome....as it always is! Great place to recharge after a Mount Major hike! I highly recommend the Lobster ???? roll or my... favorite...the Julia's Chicken Salad sandwich. Shibleys' servers make it a great experience. Read more
Beautiful view of the lake and food was top notch. I ordered the Lobster Linguine and it was amazing. The prices were pretty... high but the food was worth it. Currently there is a $6 up-charge for lobster so be prepared but totally worth it for theportions. Read more
Liked water front outdoor seating. Our waitress was friendly, the view was great and the food was okay. I would like to give a... special thanks to Marissa, she warned me off the poison ivy that I almost stepped on. She was a waitress for other table. Read more
A nice small and expensive restaurant on the bank of the river. Beautiful views outside. The restaurant is small, so the tables... are placed very close each to other. I can basically say that I was dining with some strangers together. Could see all they wereeating, could hear all they were talking about. The menu is pretty large, it was hard to make a choice. The food was good, notsomething spectacular, just good. Read more