Reviews for Jerry's Pizza & Subs in Altamonte Springs, FL

This is a hidden gem in Altamonte Springs. The pizzas here are just like the ones in New York -- and trust me, I lived in NY... for over 20 years. Jerry's pizzas are unique and the best I've had around here (including Orlando). Read more

Overall good pizza. The spicy garlic wings are a must! I enjoyed my experience and will definitely come again

Great customer service & food is delicious!!! I will only buy pizza from here support small businesses. Oh yeah the chocolate... cake is a must have. Read more

Got to say very Good Pizza. I am from Chicago and I ask them to make me a thin crust extra crispy Crust and they did it perfect... and the flavor was off the Hook and when they delivered my pizza was still nice and hot like it came out the oven it self. Read more

I'm fairly new to this part of Florida, and have tried a few other pizzerias around town, today we decided to get delivery, when... googling, I came across Jerry's, saw it was a Family owned business, and we love to support small local businesses so called inan order, the young lady who answered was so sweet and efficient, even had the courtesy to tell us there was a delay withdeliveries and asked if we'd be ok with 45min to an hour for delivery, which was totally fine, the young man who delivered thepizza walked up with a smile on his face and was so nice, told us a little back story of the pizzeria, we thanked him and senthim on his way. So between the delightful staff and the Fantastic pizza and the Gyro, OMG it tasted like my childhood, growingup on Long Island, havent had a gyro that good in about 20yrs!! it could have been a little meatier but still tasted great!! Wewill definitely be ordering again on our next "cheat day"!! Thank you so much, Sincerely~TheCheeseCakeMan~&~wife ;-) Read more

One of the best Cheesesteaks I have tasted in Fl? Worth the wait(call ahead) because they take their time with this masterpiece.... If I could give more stars I would? Read more

Have only tried the pizza and knots so far but have been happy every time. We love the standard cheese and get the white when we... want variety. I would compare the crust to a Brooklyn style from Dominos, which is great since it's been impossible to find thatfrom a local joint around here. We usually go around dinner time and have never had to wait forever after arriving at theestimated pick up window. Pic included is the 20 inch and it's just as good as the pic suggests! Read more

Ordered garlic knots, a 16-inch pizza, two salads and 2 liter of Coke and received Subway bun cut in half with garlic and... melted cheese topping , runny marinara on the side, Caesar salad douched with what appears to be Caesar salad dressing, andtasteless Pizza on the side of that. Not worth 33 bucks for a tasteless 16-inch pizza, and a burnt Subway bun that was supposedto be garlic knots. This would have ended up in the dumpster, had we not eaten all day. All tasteless. Be aware of the five starratings, probably just their friends and family. Nice job making a living, however making pizzas isn't your bag. Read more