Reviews for Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Altamonte Springs, FL

The new manager David is a doll. He took care of me in such a professional manner. I am confident he will turn this pizza parlor... around. Thank you for your service David. Read more

I was so surprised at how bad the pizza we received was. It was so burnt, hard and cold… normally some adobo can save the day,... but we actually threw the whole pie out. Pretty sure they re- cooked a fully cooked pizza since I also make food for people, Iknow it wasn’t fresh. Ordered through door dash so maybe they didn’t care. We stopped half way through throwing it out totake this pick cuz we were laughing at how bad the pizza was. It was that bad. Read more

First time here and really impressed! We were in the plaza and we seen it from afar and glad we came in! Place is absolutely... beautiful, clean and good service and delicious food! Pizza ???? very good, Maria's meatballs app. ????, The tiramisu to diefor one of the best we have ever had and the cappuccino ????. Great place can't wait to come to back again! Read more

Horrible experience. We wanted to try something different and totally regret it. We ordered for pick up. A large pizza half... cheese and half margarita with bacon. Sauce and cheese were missing on the cheese half so basically one slice of bread. Theother half never saw the basil of the Margarita but the worst of all it was sooooo burned that ended doing a frozen pizza thatwe had. Never again!!!!!! When I called to complained the lady said to wait 5 mins are you serious ??? So far the worst pizza Iever had in 8 years I lived here. Waist of money and waist of time because we live 20 mins away from this place. Read more

Great job on the pizza, be it the sauce, quality ingredient or the coal fired oven it's cooked in. Plenty of other options on... the menu, salads or sandwiches, all in large portions, served in a timely fashion, in a clean, modern environment. The wings arealso cooked in the oven so they're not oily not greasy and taste great. Prices are on the high side, inflation appears to havecaught up with Anthony's. Read more

Ever since we moved to Altamonte, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza has been on our “Must Try” list. I’m happy to report we... were not disappointed - friendly servers, a clean interior and delicious food! Even though pizza is their name, Anthony’salso offers appetizers, pasta, specialty sandwiches and dessert. We started with their garlic knots (DELISH!) not too oily whichI appreciate as well as their Eggplant Marino. Oh so yummy! The sauce.. *chef’s kiss* We then shared a square, thin-crustMargherita pizza. Presentation was lovely! We ended up ordering more of their marinara sauce for dipping. It was THATGOOD! Overall, delicious! Highly recommend! We WILL return! The only critique we had was our table was wobbly and made cuttingslightly difficult - an easy fix. Thank you for the yummies! c & c Read more

Enjoyed a really great earlier lunch here this week. Location has a nice, comfortable decor, the staff were very attentive and... prompt in getting my order and then my food out to me. The garlic knots and the Carnivora pizza were very tasty, piping hot, andvery fresh. This isn't one of the "fast casual" watch-the-pizza-being-made places, but you can place a to-go order if you like.They also have a full-service bar here that the locals seemed to like. Very worth stopping in for some great pizza and othergreat food! Read more

My new spot for pizza. Fresh ingredients, so no acid reflux or heart burn after wards. Great prices. Made fresh and served hot.