Reviews for Joe's New York Pizzeria in Alpharetta, GA
I was really surprised to find good pizza in Georgia. Growing up here it was basically crackers and ketchup. I am from Chicago... originally and naturally snobby about pizza. We are on a family road trip and decided to stop in when we spent the night inAtlanta. 10/10 highly recommend. I don't know where they found these fresh ingredients and delicious meat choices but it wasphenomenal. The only thing it needed was a touch more garlic and salt. The tomato sauce on the pizza was clearly made fresh, andthe sausage was perfectly seasoned. So good! The service was what you'd expect from teens ????. They let the kids order forthemselves, we were seated at 2 tables because of the large group. It was sweet, but most servers I know verify the order withparents due to allergies or cost. But honestly, if that's the only one small complaint to have such delicious pizza, I call it awin. Read more
All yes! I wanted to do Joe's a legit service by making multiple visits. There is nothing but goodness being produced here. This... is my 4th time eating pizza ???? here and it never fails to please. The pizza is as good as it gets, imho, in the ATL area.Starting with the crust, it is crispy, thin and holds up well. The sauce is nicely sweet and tangy. The cheese ???? has smoothquality with good flavor. I really like it. The service is always quick and friendly. They want to please your every request.Everyone makes you feel at home. My all accounts, Joe's is worth every bit of your time and money. Read more
Basic pie, nothing special. Thicker crust. Greek salad was a garden salad with feta and oil dressing.
Since I've been in Alpharetta, I have been searching for a slice of pizza that reminds me of NYC. Unfortunately, there was... nothing close to the pizza that I grew up with...the best pizza in the country! Until I ate at Joe's. It simply brought me home!So much so, that I was expecting to hear the R train rumble by. Great sauce! Great crust! Great food! Read more
The pizza is always great, I usually go here a couple times a month. Overall, this place is pretty good. It can be a little... pricey, but it is always worth it. The service is nothing to write home about. No one has ever been rude or anything, but theemployees usually don't seem that welcoming or that friendly. I am disappointed they took goat cheese off the menu, it was oneof my favorites. Read more
I tried the Calzone with fresh jalapeno and pineapple. The quantity is sumptuous and it was nice. The wait staff takes good care... of you and the place has a homely feeling. The only minor issue was the credit card did not work properly so had to pay in cash. Read more
Our waiter was super nice and they put broccoli on the pizza for us (our favorite). The name is no joke,, the pizza is as close... to NY as you can get in GA. We plan to return soon. Read more
Food is good, crust seems fresh ingredients are good too. Only real complaint I have is when I arrive to pick up my pizza,... staff seem more concerned about talking to people who had already ordered then taken care of people that were there to pick up.Not sure If they were regulars or just were bored because there were no other people in the restaurant. Read more