Reviews for The Old Mill Inn in Alfred Station, NY
If your son or daughter are attending Alfred State or University, just take a little drive 10 minutes away to this cute place.... Had a couple beers, watched the game and gulfed down one of their delicious burgers. The staff was very friendly and were onpoint with bringing out our food. We will definitely come here again, great place! Read more
First time here. Took awhile to be served however, bartender was pleasant and made great drinks and recommendations on beers.... Server was pleasant and we enjoyed our experience Read more
I had their cheese pizza yesterday and it was excellent. The crust had the perfect ratio of chewy to crispy. Seasoning was... perfect. Cheese was gooey. AND it passed the leftover test when I ate the rest, cold, several hours later. Oh, and the wings areexcellent. I'll definitely be back when I'm in the area! Read more
We hosted a party at our house with over 50 people attending. We called the Old Mill and spoke with Noah, who seemed excited for... the opportunity. Communication was super easy and he provided us with several options and suggestions. We ended up going with avariety of 16 pizzas, over 15 orders of chicken wings, pasta salad, coleslaw and a side salad. They were able to deliver all thefood on time (actually a little early) and helped place everything on our tables. The food was amazing and there wasn't a crumleft over. Our friends were raving about their "Mill Seasoning" wings. Pricing was also very reasonable. We've also had dinnerat their establishment a few times. The food was great and the staff were friendly and responsive. A+ all around. Read more
We came never having heard of The Old Mill Inn but they were open on a Monday while so many other places weren't. My drinks... were great, the service was wonderful and the food excellent. It's been a long time since we've gone out to eat and thoroughlyenjoyed all of our meal and eaten everything. The serving sizes were perfect. We highly recommend a visit or several. We knewbefore we were even done eating, and told the staff, that we would be coming back. Read more
Great place - excellent wings, awesome burgers and real french fries. You can tell that the chicken and beef come from local... farms. The wings were some of the meatiest and largest I have ever had. The burgers were fresh and lean. Great selection ofbeer! Looking forward to the addition and hope to get back soon! Read more
I'm all about family friendly places. The Owner & Bar tender where very nice to my girls. The food was definitely worth the... stop. I will be stopping in again if in the area. Read more
MY God what can I say. The food was excellent. In Western NY the true test of a restaurant are the fish fries and their... wings. My wife and I both ordered the beer battered fried fish dinners. I ordered an appetizer of fried onion rings also. Bothdone very well. The hand cut fries were perfectly cooked. The jar of Old Mill Seasoning that our waiter brought us to sprinkleover them put them over the top. The waitstaff was friendly and informed, he answered all of our questions about items on themenu. I would highly recommend that you try them. I can't wait to go back and try a deep fried steak. Oh, we like the Old MillSeasoning so much I bought a jar of it. Read more