Reviews for Valleon Cafe at Colter's Lodge in Afton, WY

My brother and I came in after a day of fishing, sat down and ordered 2 sandwiches and a one trip salad bar. There were only a... few people in there when we first got there and were told by our waitress that this was her first night... ok. After we had gotand ate our salads two other groups came in and sat close to us. One group of four ordered steaks and the other group, a coupleordered chicken fried steaks. At about the half hour mark I stared wondering what was taking so long and then I noticed theother waitress that had been helping the new girl was gone.. nowhere to be seen! Then the two other groups that came in after usby 20 or more minutes and ordered steaks and chicken fried steaks got served their meals, this was at about the 50 minute mark Iasked what was taking so long and was assured ours was on it's way....another 10 minutes and finally we were severed. The Frenchdip I ordered looked like they went and got it from Arby's. The meat was dry and not what I would expect for a "Cowboy Dip". Itook my sandwich up to the counter and asked to talk to the manager/cook, and said "I waited an hour for this while the othertables around us were all served steaks they ordered after us"... He shrugged his shoulders and said SO!! Had we not had thesalad we would have left before... Local with a bad attitude and just don't care. paid bill, left new girl her tip... won't beback... terrible service! Read more

The worst experience at a restaurant. Several people in the group felt this way. It is too bad because this historical place is... so beautiful inside. The food is awful. Burgers are overcooked, fries taste like they are from last week. We asked for morefries as they weren't edible. The new fries were honestly slightly better but still I only ate a couple as I needed somethingfor food. Others had steak, not good. Anyways, I wish we read the reviews before stopping at this cool historic spot. Read more

Eggs, hasbrowns cooked to taste. Great customer service. Very nice decor. Had a wonderful time. Very highly recommended.

Food was very tasty but steak was small, overcooked on outside and undercooked on inside. Salad bar was unattractive, browning... lettuce. Portions were also small for price. Read more

I?m pretty easy to please and have never left a negative review about food. Usually, if it?s good enough then fine. However,... everyone?s food at our table was cold (not lukewarm, actually cold), server was nice but forgetful and neglectful, salad bar waspicked over with nothing but white iceberg lettuce (no green lettuce anywhere). And certainly overpriced considering all thequality we didn?t get. If was pointless to bring our concerns up to server as she already wasn?t following up with basics likewho had what and refilling drinks?half of our party couldn?t get a refill beyond their first fill. I did, however, share myconcerns with the cashier and she was nice and apologized and said she?d tell the kitchen. However, no discount was given norwas the manager brought out to address our concerns. 7-2-22, party of 6, slow night, most tables were empty so it wasn?t busy.The tables have notes asking for reviews, so I did (I opted out of asking for the free dessert that comes with leaving areview). I would recommend this places fixes all the 1-2 star reviews concerns I read here (who seem to have similarexperiences) before they ask for more reviews. Read more

Out of cold tea. Did not know what sides they had. 30 minutes after ordering, waitress came back to tell us they were out of two... of our the 5 things we ordered. Fried burnt. I ask for BLT no mayo, sub mustard. Brought with mayo on it. Sent it back. THEYSCRAPED OFF THE MAYO AND SERVED IT AGAIN with half the bacon missing and mayo still on the bread and lettuce and on the side ofthe plate. Read more

The best thing about it was the horseradish. Seriously, the entire meal was cold, the charge for $1.99 each for sauted... mushrooms and onions was very scanty, and even when I sent it back to heat up, it still came back luke warm. The hamburgersteak was tasty, but the rest was terrible. My husband had the prime ribs, and once again, the sides were all cold. He said iswas like a Vegas buffet...just mediocre. There was no salt and pepper which I guess was not a huge deal but after they"warmed" my plate, the.corn...still not warm, was very bland. Didn't end up eating the corn nor the potatoes. The waitresswa very good though, so there's that. Read more

We ate there Saturday 4/9/22. The service was great, Sierra was very friendly and quick to bring our requested items. However,... THE FOOD WAS HORRIBLE. My husband's burger was overcooked, my daughter's chicken strips were overcooked, the two other people atour table ordered the tenderloin and received a very thinly sliced cut of sirloin, that was full of FAT. My baked potato wasunder cooked and super hard, i couldn't even eat it. We did not ask for a discount or for any of our food to go back- we willjust never eat there again. Ever. It used to be really good food, i'm not sure what has happened. Read more