Reviews for Fathom Restaurant in Afton, WY
So I went to this location the other day for supper. I ordered a ribeye asked for loaded mashed potatoes because they don't... offer a baked potato. Also had a option for corn as a side. ( which they come to find out when my plate arrived they didn'thave. ) So this review is not ment to come across as rude but more so think of it how do we become better? I asked for my steakto be cooked medium rare. This meal also comes with a salad. Overall 1-10 id give you a score of 5 out of 10. Most of thosepoints go to the wait staff btw. Extremely professional and polite. Salad little to no cheese on it there was water in bowl itcame in. Two slim slices of tomato. Basicly iceberg lettuce cut up with dressing. I'd like to see it kicked up. Chucks ofcheese,carrots ect for og level offer a Cesar salad option. The side of mashed potatoes which quick note are made from realpotatoes. Much appreciated. Get the serving size up meaning more also offer baked potato option. Now the steak find you a goodsteak rub or seasoning. My steak I personally think medium rare would have been cooked a little more through so be checking yourmeat temps while cooking. Also offer the option for onions and mushrooms as a topping. Finally the veggies. Don't offersomething your out of. Secondly to substitute it with a carrot 2 tiny peices of broccoli and 2 thin slices of zucchini and apeice of coliflower. While pretty back to tiny portions up them. Now I know there is much more on the menu food wise this isjust what I ordered and my 2 cents on the experience. Check them out might be the greatest food since sliced bread but for me awyoming native I want big portions my next door state is idaho so I expect a spud and if mashed alot of them. A medium steak isslightly pink on the inside not reddish. The salad hey if it sucks well more room for main coarse. Also cheesecake for dessertis a nice touch in my opinion. But most of all keep up the great Customer service makes me happy to know you have wyom Read more
In Afton for three days last week. Once we found Fathom we dined nowhere else! The reviews brought us in, the excellent food and... friendly service kept us coming back. I enjoyed Murgh Malai Tikka twice in a row- a good portion of tender chicken breastsmarinated in yogurt, sautéed with butter, onions and peppers and served with saffron rice and garlic naan bread. Little pots ofmango chutney and cilantro sauce on the side. Husband had Grilled Fish twice too- served Caribbean style with white fishgrilled then topped with a sweet stew of tomatoes, peppers and onions and flavored with herbs and spices. He also added a Naanbread and we split a Caprese salad first. For our third visit that same week we split a Prime Rib dinner ($29) just asking fora second plate ($11 gets you the plate with salad bar and Saffron rice and Naan bread of your own). Lean and delicious andtender and certainly large enough to split for the two of us to be very satisfied. The staff told the story of losing theirother jobs during the pandemic and cooking food for their neighbors from home. They were encouraged by the neighbors to open arestaurant after another venture did not survive the difficult times. They are located right on the main drag through town andunder the elk antler arch. The multi-ethnic staff has sure brought the flavors of the world to tiny Afton. Definitely worth avisit- or three! Read more
I had the butter chicken curry. Definitely yummy. Very good food for the price. Friendly and helpful staff!
The best home made burger my son had! Chicken tikka is one of the best authentic curry i ever had you can choose the level of... spice you want! servers are all friendly and clean restaurant in the middle of no where! definitely coming back afteryellowstone trip! Read more
The family who runs this place is so friendly and down to earth. The owner used to be a head chef on a ship! The place is new... and clean. The food is so delicious and well cooked! The flavors are so diverse and good. Sooo many options to choose from. Theygave us extra rice free of charge. Love this place highly recommend. Read more
Really enjoyed my Chicken Tikka Masala. Also had the Chicken Korma and it was yummy as well! Even though we both ordered Indian... dishes, their menu had great variety. If I am ever back in Afton, we would definitely eat there again! Read more
We were thrilled to see this new restaurant in our valley that offers a variety of different cuisines. Tonight we had the... Chicken Tikka Masala and the tandoori chicken. Both meals were flavorful and delicious. The garlic naan was also a hit!! Theservice was fast and friendly. The restaurant was clean and inviting. It was a good amount of food for a reasonable price.Definitely worth a stop of your traveling through Star Valley, or if you're a local. Read more
Came here from out of town with a couple coworkers. The grocery store food was getting old so we decided to go out. Man are we... glad we chose Fathom! We went in with high hopes and the food absolutely exceeded our expectations. We got appetizers, dinnerand dessert. The Indian dishes were phenomenal and the naan was some of the best I?ve ever had. The appetizers and dessert wereall delicious as well. The restaurant had a fun and welcoming vibe, and the service was absolutely fantastic. Everyone was sonice and the food came out quickly even on a busy Friday night. 10/10 if you find yourself in Afton you gotta try this placeout. You won?t regret it. Read more